|
|
Contents of This Section
- What is the relevance of the fields
of gene therapy and genomics to brain aneurysms?
- What is gene therapy and how does
it relate to the Human Genome Project?
- What is gene transfer?
- How does gene transfer to blood
vessels work?
- How do you deliver genes to blood
vessels?
- What progress has been made in
gene therapy for diseases affecting brain blood vessels?
1. What is the relevance
of the fields of gene therapy and genomics to brain aneurysms?
As you read the section
on Gene Therapy, below, and the section on Genomics elsewhere
in this Website (
take me to the Genomics section now),
you will learn that understanding the genetic basis for why
aneurysms form and rupture is extremely important. Why? Because
this knowledge may lead to the identification of a precise
molecular target for gene-based aneurysm screening and treatment
and, hopefully, will pave the way to preventing the formation
and rupture of these lesions altogether. This may seem like
a long shot, but my colleagues and I have already made great
strides in the fields of cerebrovascular gene therapy and
genomics, and we're dedicated to making this dream a reality.
Here are some studies published in premier cerebrovascular,
gene therapy and neurosurgical journals, reflecting my personal
involvement in this field, and some important scientific advances
we've made to date:
- VG Khurana et al. Adenovirus-mediated
gene transfer to human cerebral arteries. Journal of
Cerebral Blood Flow and Metabolism, 20:1360-1371,
2000.
- Comment:
This article reported the first time that human brain
arteries were genetically modified. In this work,
our goal was to use gene transfer technology (see
below) to improve the function of human brain arteries.
By demonstrating that the function of normal human
brain arteries can be genetically enhanced (by transferring
the vasodilator-producing endothelial nitric oxide
synthase gene), this work paves the way for the improvement
or functional restoration of brain arteries that are
abnormal or diseased (e.g., in brain aneurysms, cerebral
vasospasm, Moya Moya disease, atherosclerosis, and
arteriovenous malformations).
- VG Khurana et al. Protective
vasomotor effects of in vivo recombinant endothelial nitric
oxide synthase gene expression in a canine model of cerebral
vasospasm. Stroke, 33:782-789, 2002.
- Comment:
This article reported that endothelial nitric oxide
synthase gene transfer could be used to protect brain
arteries against the development of vasospasm in a
mammalian model that mimics brain arterial spasm caused
by aneurysmal rupture (experimental subarachnoid hemorrhage).
- VG Khurana et al. A direct
mechanical method for accurate and efficient adenoviral
vector delivery to tissues. Gene Therapy, 10:443-452,
2003.
- Comment:
Here, we report a novel mechanical technique to significantly
enhance the delivery of genes to blood vessels and
other tissues, with the goal being more accurate and
safer gene transfer in the setting of a wide variety
of animal and human disease states. This work led
to U.S. Patent 6,821,264 which records the
design and applications of the surgical "GeneBrush"
(
take me to the GeneBrush
section now).
- VG Khurana & FB Meyer.
Translational paradigms in cerebrovascular gene transfer.
Journal of Cerebral Blood Flow and Metabolism,
23:1251-1262, 2003.
- Comment:
This article reviews the advances in gene transfer
technology as applied to brain blood vessels. It summarizes
the essential concepts and practice of gene transfer
and gene therapy, and how these concepts and practices
may eventually apply to the successful treatment of
brain vessel diseases.
- VG Khurana et al. Endothelial
nitric oxide synthase gene polymorphisms predict susceptibility
to aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage and cerebral vasospasm.
Journal of Cerebral Blood Flow and Metabolism,
24:291-297, 2004.
- Comment:
This work reported for the first time the link between
relatively frequent variations in the endothelial
nitric oxide synthase gene (eNOS, a gene encoding
the protein that leads to the production of the critical
blood vessel dilating molecule, nitric oxide) and
brain aneurysms.
- VG Khurana et al. The presence
of tandem endothelial nitric oxide synthase gene polymorphisms
identifying brain aneurysms more prone to rupture. Journal
of Neurosurgery, 102:526-531, 2005.
- Comment:
This article reports brain aneurysms that are more
prone to rupturing can be identified according to
an aneurysm patient's eNOS genetic profile. It is
hoped that this work (Patent pending) may lead
to the development of a simple, rapid and cost-effective
screening tool for brain aneurysm rupture.
2. What is gene therapy and
how does it relate to the Human Genome Project?
In order to understand
what the term "gene therapy" means, the two
key words "gene" and "therapy"
must first be defined:
- A gene is a piece of biological
data that forms part of our "genome".
Our genome is our entire DNA or genetic code which is
essentially derived from our biological parents following
conception and is responsible for our development. Although
our development is undoubtedly intertwined with the influences
exerted on us by our respective environments, we are essentially
the products of our genes. The information contained (i.e.,
encoded) in genes is converted through complex
molecular processes known as transcription and
translation into proteins. In short, "genes
code for proteins". Proteins are large molecules
that represent the fundamental building blocks of the
tissues that make up our bodies. There is an enormous
variety of proteins in our bodies as they have evolved
to play unique and essential roles in cell structure and
function. For example, some proteins are enzymes involved
in an array of metabolic pathways, others participate
in structural support, while others act as "receptors"
or "channels" or "molecular motors"
or "chaperones" in cellular communication, signaling,
gating, and transport. Note that proteins may have more
than one function. There are approximately 30,000 genes
in the human genome, but there a many many more proteins
(i.e., one gene can encode for many proteins, based on
the occurrence of "posttranscriptional-posttranslational
modifications").
- Therapy refers to treatment,
the ultimate aim of which is to cure a disease process.
When we think of disease processes, it becomes apparent
that many diseases are in fact associated with a problem
stemming from the quantity (i.e., too little or too much)
or quality (i.e., defective function) of a particular
protein or group of proteins. That is, the "molecular
defect" underlying a given disease is often related
to some specific protein abnormality.
- Gene therapy is a relatively
new and evolving technology that aims to treat a disease
by genetic means. Please note (I feel that this is
such an important point to note, I'm going to highlight
it in red!) that human
gene therapy does not and should not seek to create new
life forms or to modify our species. Rather, it does and
should seek to improve the quality of a sick patient's
life by replacing or restoring one or more essential protein
products that they may be missing. The principles
of gene therapy (see Figure 1, below) imply
that if we can pinpoint the precise molecular defect in
a given disease and know the sequence of the gene that
specifically codes for that protein, then we can replace
or restore the protein in the affected person (or "host")
by packaging the coding gene into a suitable biological
vehicle (called a "vector") and introducing
that vector into the host (see 2., below, which describes
the science underlying gene therapy).
Human Gene Therapy
Model:

Figure 1 shows
key components of a human gene therapy model. In the ideal
scenario, a patient with a disease whose precise molecular
defect is known undergoes safe and specific gene therapy,
resulting in an objective clinical benefit (ideally, a "cure").
The promise of gene
therapy is that this therapeutic technology will one day
be safe, widely available, and highly effective in curing
human diseases. However, two important things can be said
about this statement:
- First, gene therapy is still
in its infancy. Although hundreds of clinical protocols
have been approved and used in thousands of patients to
date, the number of successful outcomes is heavily outweighed
by unsuccessful or ineffective ones. This in no way detracts
from the enormous, dedicated and often heroic efforts
undertaken by the many institutions and individuals involved
in the research and development of this unique form of
therapy - it just means we still have a lot to learn and
a long way to go.
- Second, the evolution of gene therapy
is closely associated with the findings of the Human
Genome Project (
see Genomics section). This project,
a joint initiative of government and private sectors,
commenced over a decade ago and aimed to decode the entire
human genome. This epic undertaking in "genomics"
is now essentially complete. Now, in our possession is
the molecular blueprint of human life. However, perhaps
an even greater challenge lies ahead, namely, "functional
genomics" and "proteomics" [i.e.,
trying to unravel the links between (1) the huge array
of genetic sequences we now know, (2) the vast number
of proteins they encode, many or perhaps most of which
we didn't even know existed, and (3) the precise functions
of those proteins and their relevance to disease].
3. What is gene transfer?
Gene transfer is the
science behind gene therapy (see Figure 2, below).
That is, gene therapy relies on gene transfer technology.
What comprises gene transfer technology? There are four key
components:
- A therapeutic gene. This
is a specific gene of interest which we know codes
for a protein that is deficient or somehow defective in
a given patient. Examples of therapeutic genes are, say,
DNAs for the protein-enzymes endothelial nitric oxide
synthase (eNOS) and heme oxygenase-1 (HO-1). These genes
code for the potentially therapeutic proteins eNOS and
HO-1, respectively (
for more information see articles listed in the Key
References section of this Website). These proteins
are thought to be deficient or defective in brain arteries
following rupture of an aneurysm, and this fact may contribute
to the development of cerebral vasospasm following aneurysmal
rupture (
I want to find out more about the mechanism of cerebral
vasospasm, so take me to Cerebral Vasospasm
now). There is an enormous number of potentially therapeutic
genes that can be used in vectors. This number is increasing
as the human genomics and proteomics initiatives progress
(
see Genomics). Note that one or
more therapeutic genes can now be incorporated into
the same vector.
- A vector. This is a biological
agent into which the therapeutic gene can be inserted
or "packaged" and which serves the following
functions: (i) gaining entry into the cells of the patient
or "host", followed by (ii) allowing the host's
transcriptional and translational machinery to convert
the therapeutic gene (carried by the vector) into the
therapeutic protein. A vector may momentarily contact
some sort of receptor (akin to a molecular doorknob) on
the cell surface to gain entry into the cell. An example
of a vector is a common cold virus (adenovirus)
that has been engineered not to replicate itself (i.e.,
is relatively safe because it has been rendered replication-incompetent
by genetic engineering) but can still act as a viable
molecular carrier into which a gene (or genes) of interest
(see above) and a promoter (see below) may be inserted.
Another type of vector is naked DNA itself (i.e., a "plasmid")
which may be used alone or in combination with a coat
of fat particles (lipids), the latter of which
is called a plasmid-liposome conjugate. Each of
these vectors (note that there are many more!) has specific
advantages and disadvantages related to how well they
can enter cells, which cells they can in fact enter, how
they work once inside the host's cells, how long they
can work for, and their individual safety-risk profiles.
[
More detailed information can be found in relevant review
articles; e.g., see Khurana & Katusic (2001), Chen
et al. (1998) and Khurana and Meyer (2003) in the Key
References section of this Website].
- A promoter. This is a relatively
small genetic sequence that is also part of the vector.
It drives "transcription", i.e., the process
whereby the information contained in the therapeutic gene
(i.e., the cDNA) is converted into messenger (m)RNA (which
is the genetic macromolecule whose information is "translated"
into the therapeutic protein)
- A delivery device. This
is some physical instrument that is used to aid in transferring
and/or directing the vector to the appropriate tissue
target in the patient. Examples of delivery devices include
an injector-needle, a catheter, a stent, and a surgical
paintbrush (see 4., below).
General Mechanism
of Gene Transfer:

Figure 2 illustrates
the mechanism of gene transfer, which represents the science
behind gene therapy. It involves packaging a gene of interest
(1; which codes for the therapeutic protein) into
a suitable vector (2). The vector is (using an appropriate
delivery device; see below) brought near to cells in
the target tissue (i.e., the host's tissue in which
we want the therapeutic protein to be produced or "synthesized"),
and gains entry into these cells (3). This entry may be aided
by contact with a receptor and/or a coreceptor found (i.e.,
"expressed") on the target cell surface. The vector
eventually makes its way into the nucleus of the host cell
(4); this region of the cell houses the host's genomic (or
"native") DNA. Depending on the type of vector used,
the cDNA in the vector may or may not become one with the
host's native DNA. Regardless of this event, using the transcriptional
and translational machinery of the host, the vector (without
replicating itself) allows the host's cell to produce large
amounts of the therapeutic protein (5). This protein may stay
within the cell (e.g., an enzyme), or may move out of the
cell (i.e., a secreted protein or protein fragment known as
a polypeptide). Either way, the protein's presence should
have a beneficial (or therapeutic) effect on the host. Depending
on the vector used, the host may mount an inflammatory
response to the vector, which can limit the effectiveness
of this technology. Much progress is being made regarding
the reduction of the inflammatory (immune-stimulatory) effects
of vectors.
4. How does gene transfer
to blood vessels work?
In accordance with the
gene transfer mechanism described above, gene transfer to
blood vessels works as follows (see Figure 3, below).
Say certain brain arteries in a patient are known to be diseased
in that they are not producing enough of a protein such as
eNOS or HO-1 (
visit the Key References section
for more information). This can occur, e.g., in the setting
of cerebral vasospasm following rupture of an aneurysm (
I want to find out more about the mechanism of cerebral vasospasm,
so take me to Cerebral Vasospasm now).
In such scenarios, a therapeutic gene of interest (e.g., cDNA
for eNOS or HO-1) is packaged into a suitable "clinical-grade"
vector (e.g., a safe and highly purified adenovirus
that has been engineered to be unable to reproduce itself,
but still able to carry the therapeutic gene and allow its
conversion into a therapeutic protein). The vector is then
delivered to the target vessel(s) using a suitable delivery
device (see 4. below). The vector particles now make their
way into the cells of the target artery in the host [cell-entry
in the case of an adenovirus typically involves attachment
of outer parts of the adenovirus to a certain host-cell receptor
known as the Coxsackie virus-adenovirus receptor (CAR) and
an "integrin" coreceptor]. The vector particles
eventually reach the nucleus of the host's cell, and there
they allow the host's molecular machinery to produce the therapeutic
protein (e.g., "recombinant" eNOS or HO-1).
Note that in the case of an adenovirus, when the vector enters
the nucleus, the adenovirus vector's own DNA does not incorporate
itself into (i.e., does not fuse or "integrate"
with) the host cell's original (or "native") DNA
(i.e., it remains "episomal"). Other vectors,
on the other hand, do fuse. The act of fusion versus nonfusion
has interesting consequences; these are elaborated elsewhere
[ for
a thorough and colorful review of this topic, see Khurana
& Meyer (2003) in the Key References
section of this Website].
Mechanism of Vascular
Gene Transfer:
Figure 3 shows
how gene transfer works in a blood vessel. A vector
(1) incorporating a gene of interest is transferred into a
target blood vessel (2). This event is called "transduction".
If we look at a cross-section (3) through the same region
of the blood vessel wall that the vector has entered, we can
see that the vector has caused the production of the therapeutic
protein (yellow circles in 3) encoded by the gene of interest.
Of course, the vector may not enter all of the cells of the
target tissue, and so the therapeutic protein is produced
only in cells in which all of the above have taken place (namely,
accurate delivery, efficient transduction, and effective biosynthesis).
5. How do you deliver
genes to blood vessels?
There are several ways
in which vectors containing therapeutic genes can be delivered
to a blood vessel (see Figure 4, below). First, note
that the "route of delivery" may be through
the central opening (lumen) of the artery (i.e., "intraluminal"
delivery) or via the outer wall (adventitia) of the
artery (i.e., "adventitial" or "perivascular"
delivery). The structure of an artery is discussed elsewhere
( take
me to Brain Artery Structure now).
Second, the "technique of delivery" may be
associated with a physical method (mechanical approach)
or a nonphysical method (chemical or molecular
approach) aimed at either enhancing targeting of the vector
to a particular site (or tissue) in the body (i.e., increasing
the accuracy of the transduction process) or improving
the chances of the vector entering the cells of the target
tissue (i.e., increasing the efficiency of the transduction
process), or both. Third, there are different devices that
can be used for the delivery of vectors. For example, in the
intraluminal approach, a catheter (essentially a small,
flexible hollow tube) can be threaded through the arterial
tree to (or close to) the specific artery into which the vector
[now in the form of a liquid ("solution" or "suspension")]
can be "squirted". Alternatively, a catheter can
be used to release (or "deploy") a stent (essentially
a tube that expands against the innermost surface of the artery);
it is a special type of stent of course (a bioactive stent),
namely, it has been impregnated with a vector, or may contain
previously transduced cells capable of producing the therapeutic
product. In the perivascular approach, a small paintbrush
can be used to gently, safely, and very effectively massage
a vector into the wall of an artery from its outer surface.
This is a form of mechanical transduction that has the advantages
of being direct, intuitive (i.e., easy to understand and easy
to use), and relatively rapid and efficient [Khurana et al.,
Gene Therapy (2003), Khurana and Meyer (2003), U.S.
Patent No. 6,821,264;
Visit the Key References or Genebrush
Sections). Another type of perivascular approach is to use
a needle to inject a vector into the space surrounding
the artery. This can be done close to the artery itself (i.e.,
local delivery), or at some distance from the artery (i.e.,
remote delivery). If the vector is injected close to the outer
wall of the target artery, it typically has to be contained
in an outer catheter or sheath; if it is injected remote to
the target artery (say, into the cerebrospinal fluid that
circulates in and around the brain and spinal cord - like
a "spinal" or "intrathecal"
injection), then it will diffuse throughout these structures
in a more nonspecific manner. All of these approaches have
been shown in gene transfer studies to be effective in causing
successful transduction of arteries. They are all subject
to ongoing development.
Regardless of the delivery
approach, the main goal is to safely, accurately,
and efficiently get vector particles into cells of the
target artery, where the particles can then use the host's
molecular machinery to produce the desired therapeutic protein.
Techniques of Vascular
Gene Delivery:

Figure 4 illustrates
different techniques (1 - 4) that can be used to deliver genes
to an artery. (1) A hollow catheter (blue tube in the
figure); note the vector (yellow) particles being squirted
into the lumen of the artery. There are other types of catheters
with special chambers that intentionally trap the vector in
a confined space and thereby allow transduction to occur along
only a relatively small (finite) length of the artery. (2)
A stent (yellow hashed cylindrical sheet in the figure;
only one-half of the stent is shown) can be used; this is
in fact deployed by special catheters, and expands against
the inner surface of the artery. Vector particles or vector-transduced
cells are impregnated into the stent. (3) A needle can
be used to inject a vector solution (yellow droplets in the
figure) into the space surrounding an artery. (4) A small
surgical paintbrush can be used to gently and directly
massage a vector-containing solution or paste (yellow streak
in figure) into the wall of an artery. Note that a "gene
gun" (not shown here) has also been developed to
fire vectors such as naked DNA particles directly into tissues.
6. What progress has been
made in gene therapy for diseases affecting brain blood vessels?
Since the first gene
delivery to brain arteries carried out in 1995, there have
been dozens of studies that have characterized the mechanism
and benefits of this approach in the brain circulation.
This area has been recently
reviewed by Khurana & Meyer (2003), and an interested
reader is referred to this article and others in the Gene
Therapy Key References section of
this Website.
|